Most people think of Florida in terms of beaches, theme parks and golf courses. Beneath that is a category of property most buyers never encounter. This piece looks at several that were reported on in 2026. It is commentary on published reporting: none of these properties is listed by The Keyes Company or by me, prices are as reported on the dates in the Works Cited, and any of them may since have sold, changed price or been withdrawn.
Bannon Island, Lake Marion
A 23.3-acre private island in Lake Marion near Haines City was reported in 2026 as listed for $12 million, the first time it had been offered for sale in well over a century (This Is Money; Orlando Weekly, “Bannon Island”). It is reachable only by boat, helicopter or seaplane, and sits roughly between Orlando and Tampa (This Is Money). The property has been held by one family since the 1880s; its original two-story house dates from 1887 and is reported to have come through Hurricane Charley in 2004, alongside a modern addition, a separate duplex, groves and outbuildings (This Is Money).
For any island property, the first questions are practical: how utilities, septic and fire protection are provided, what access permits exist, how the structures are insured, and which lenders will finance a home with no road access.
Howell Key and East Sister Rock, Florida Keys
Orlando Weekly reported that Howell Key, a roughly 10-acre private island about a mile off Summerland Key, returned to the market at $16.9 million after being offered at $21.9 million in 2024, with a main house completed in 2012, a guest house, a pool and a helipad (Orlando Weekly, “Howell Key”). Off Marathon, a listing for East Sister Rock Island describes about 6.5 acres including surrounding submerged land, a three-bedroom main residence with a guest house, solar and wind power with battery storage, a backup generator, desalination and cistern storage (CENTURY 21). Off-grid systems are maintenance obligations as much as they are features; ask for service records and replacement costs.
Lesser-known Pinellas waterfront areas
A Pinellas brokerage’s guide points to several waterfront areas that draw less attention than their better-known neighbors (MV Collective):
- The Pink Streets, in Greater Pinellas Point at the southern tip of St. Petersburg, known for concrete streets poured in the 1920s with a pink tint.
- Jungle Prada, on Boca Ciega Bay on St. Petersburg’s west side, with a large oak canopy and a long recorded history.
- Ozona, an unincorporated village between Dunedin and Palm Harbor.
- Harbor Bluffs, in the Belleair area, on a bluff above the Intracoastal Waterway.
Elevation is often mentioned in descriptions of these areas. Do not rely on it. Flood risk and insurance requirements are parcel-specific: check FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center, get an elevation certificate where one exists, and get an insurance quote before the inspection period ends.
Hillsboro Beach
Hillsboro Beach occupies a 3.2-mile barrier island along State Road A1A in Broward County, with one road running its length, no commercial properties, and no street lights, a choice associated with protecting sea-turtle nesting (MILLION). A town with no commercial district means daily errands happen outside town limits; that is the practical point to weigh.
Villa Amalfi, Boca Raton
A newly built Boca Raton home known as Villa Amalfi was reported at $11.5 million, designed around a 125-year-old olive tree imported from California and set in a reflecting pool within a glass atrium (Realtor.com; LMTonline). It is covered in more detail in Florida’s Wildest Homes.
Weeki Wachee riverfront
A listing in Weeki Wachee Gardens, Hernando County, offers 50 feet of frontage on the spring-fed Weeki Wachee River, which the listing describes as holding about 74 degrees year-round (William Raveis). Riverfront lots in spring systems carry their own rules: check zoning, setbacks, any environmental permits needed for docks or seawalls, and local short-term rental rules before planning a use.
What this means
Unusual properties are not hidden by anyone; they simply sit outside most people’s search filters. What they share is complexity: access, utilities, insurance, financing and permitting all take more work than for a typical home. If something here interests you, start with those questions, and work with an agent licensed in Florida who will put them to the listing agent.